سلام برای خیلی از دوستان این سوال پیش می اید که بعد از تحویل مقاله به ژورنال چه اتفاقی می افتد و مراحل پیشرفت کار چیست در انجمن خودمان هم این سوال هر از چندگاه معمولا طرح میشود. این راهنما را دیدم و به نظرم نکات ساده و کلی با اینحال هنوز مفیدی دارد. لینک اینجاست.

https://www.editage.com/insights/pee...ng-at-journals

این دومی هم را روی sage دیدم که یک چک لیستی برای لحظه قبل از تحویل مقاله تهیه کرده و اینهم به نظرم بی فایده برای دوستان نباشد.

7 steps to publishing in a scientific journal

Before you hit “submit,” here’s a checklist (and pitfalls to avoid)


https://www.elsevier.com/connect/7-s...ntific-journal

موفق باشید

The peer review process for journal publication is essentially a quality control mechanism. It is a process by which experts evaluate scholarly works, and its objective is to ensure a high quality of published science. However, peer reviewers do not make the decision to accept or reject papers. At most, they recommend a decision. At peer-reviewed journals, decision-making authority rests solely with journal editors or the journal’s editorial board. Indeed, it is the journal editor who is considered to be central to the decision making process.1

Journal decision-making process

Typically, after a paper is submitted to a journal, a journal editor screens the manuscript and decides whether or not to send it for full peer review. Only after clearing the initial screening is the manuscript sent to one or more peer reviewers. Finally, journal editors or the journal’s editorial board consider the peer reviewers’ reports and make the final decision to accept or reject the manuscript for publication.
Initial screening
Approximately 3 million manuscripts are submitted to journals every year.1 Given the large volume of manuscript submissions, more and more journals follow a policy of screening papers before sending them for full peer review. During the initial screening, journal editors mainly check the following: Journal editors typically look at hundreds of manuscripts a year. One of the first items that editors will look at is the cover letter, and they may not get further than the cover letter if the study does not seem interesting enough. Therefore, it is imperative that authors craft a well-written cover letter that highlights the significance and strength of their research as well as provides a good reason why the manuscript is a good fit for the journal. Editors will then go through the abstract and may even skim through the introduction, figures and tables, or other sections of the paper to determine whether the manuscript passes their quality threshold.